WishGiven vs MyRegistry (2025)
MyRegistry has been around since 2005 and offers solid universal registry capabilities through partnerships with major retailers. But its age shows: the interface is dated, the browser button has inconsistent compatibility across modern websites, and gift-givers still face account requirements to interact with your registry. WishGiven is built for 2026 — a clean interface, a reliable browser extension for any site, and anonymous claiming so anyone can buy for you without barriers.
Best for a modern universal wishlist with zero friction for buyers
Best if you want deep integration with specific partner retailers
Ready to try WishGiven for free?
Build your list in minutes. No credit card required.
Feature comparison
Browser extension (any website)
MyRegistry's browser button has inconsistent support on modern sites. WishGiven's extension is built for current web standards.
Anonymous claiming (no account for gift-givers)
MyRegistry requires buyers to have an account to mark gifts as purchased. WishGiven uses anonymous claiming — no account needed.
Modern, clean interface
WishGiven is built with a contemporary design. MyRegistry's UI reflects its 2005 origins.
Social friend layer
Follow friends, see shared wish activity, coordinate group gifts.
No ads on your registry page
MyRegistry displays ads and sponsored products on registry pages. WishGiven pages are ad-free.
Free to use
Both offer free core functionality.
Why the differences matter
Anonymous claiming removes the last barrier to gifting
MyRegistry marks items as 'purchased' only when a buyer logs in and manually updates the registry. Most buyers never do this — they just buy and move on. This leads to duplicate gifts. WishGiven's anonymous claiming is different: when someone wants to give you a gift, they click Claim, enter their name, and the item is marked for them. The gift-giver immediately goes to buy it, and everyone can see it's taken without any account needed.
A browser extension built for the modern web
MyRegistry's universal browser button was built for an older era of e-commerce. On many modern single-page applications, dynamic product pages, or mobile-first sites, the button doesn't reliably capture product data. WishGiven's Chrome extension is actively maintained for modern web standards and works reliably on today's retail sites — from major chains to DTC brands to Etsy shops.
Which should you choose?
Choose WishGiven if…
- You want a modern, clean interface for your registry
- You want gift-givers to claim without any account
- You want an ad-free registry page
- You want reliable extension support on new and modern retail sites
- You want social features to coordinate with friends
Choose MyRegistry if…
- You need deep integration with specific legacy retail chains
- You want a registry search feature so guests can find you by name
- You prefer a long-established platform with a large user base
Frequently asked questions
Start your free wishlist today
Add items from any store, share with anyone, and let gift-givers claim without creating an account.
Create your wishlist — it's free