WishGiven vs Babylist (2025)
Babylist popularised the universal registry concept and is excellent if you want a curated baby-brand marketplace. But it comes with trade-offs: sellers pay to be featured, purchases are routed through Babylist's system which adds friction, and gift-givers need an account to interact. WishGiven gives you the same 'add from anywhere' freedom with direct purchase links and anonymous claiming — no platform in the middle.
Best universal registry with zero platform fees
Best if you want a dedicated baby-brand marketplace
Ready to try WishGiven for free?
Build your list in minutes. No credit card required.
Feature comparison
Add items from any store
Both platforms support adding from any URL. Babylist also has a native brand marketplace.
Anonymous claiming (no account required for gift-givers)
Babylist requires gift-givers to create a Babylist account. WishGiven has zero sign-up friction for buyers.
Direct purchase link (no platform redirect)
Babylist routes purchases through their checkout for retailer-listed items. WishGiven links directly to the retailer.
Browser extension
Babylist's button works on major retailers. WishGiven's extension works on any product page.
Zero platform fees for buyers
Babylist charges a convenience fee on purchases made through their platform for some items.
Social friend layer
Follow friends, coordinate group gifts, see activity across your network.
Why the differences matter
No account wall for your baby shower guests
You've spent time building your Babylist registry and shared the link with friends and family. Then your aunt — or anyone without a Babylist account — hits a sign-up screen before they can even see what you need. WishGiven's anonymous claiming removes this entirely. A guest clicks your link, sees your items, claims one, and goes to buy it. No account, no email verification, no platform friction.
Your guests buy from the retailer, not from Babylist
When someone purchases a Babylist-listed item, the transaction goes through Babylist's system. That means an extra step, a potential convenience fee, and Babylist sitting between you and the retailer. WishGiven stores the direct product URL — your guests click and land on the exact product page at the store you chose. No middleman, no markup.
Which should you choose?
Choose WishGiven if…
- You want a frictionless experience for older relatives or international guests
- You shop at boutique or independent baby stores not in Babylist's marketplace
- You want to avoid platform convenience fees
- You want direct links to retailer product pages
- You're creating a wishlist for any occasion beyond a baby registry
Choose Babylist if…
- You want a dedicated baby brand marketplace in one place
- You want group gifting features specific to baby registries
- You value Babylist's editorial curation and baby product guides
Frequently asked questions
Start your free wishlist today
Add items from any store, share with anyone, and let gift-givers claim without creating an account.
Create your wishlist — it's free